Disclosure: TopShelf Mushrooms and Pilly Labs are operated by the same team. This page includes promotional links to Pilly Labs. Product comparisons are based on current labels, prices, policies, and cited research.
Two “relax” gummies, two very different formulas
Cornbread Hemp’s Mushroom Relax Gummies and Pilly Labs’ Reishi Relax Gummies both use the word “relax” on the label, and both lean on reishi mushroom as an anchor ingredient. But once you get past the marketing copy and into the actual Supplement Facts panel, the two products are built on different philosophies. One is a simple, three-ingredient daytime formula. The other is a five-ingredient nighttime blend with a heavier botanical stack. Neither label proves the finished gummy works — only the individual ingredients have been studied, and usually at different doses than what’s in these gummies. Here’s what each label actually says, side by side.
Cornbread Mushroom Relax Gummies: what’s on the label
Cornbread’s Relax formula is built around three ingredients per Cornbread Hemp’s official Mushroom Relax Gummies page:
- Organic Reishi (10:1 fruiting body extract) — 500 mg
- Organic KSM-66® Ashwagandha Extract — 250 mg
- Organic L-Theanine — 50 mg
Those amounts are per serving, and Cornbread defines a serving as 2 gummies. The jar holds 50 gummies (25 servings), and it’s priced at $34.99 regular, or $22.74 per bottle on the subscribe-and-save plan. The label directs adults to take 2 gummies daily and notes that effects build over roughly two weeks of consistent use. The formula is USDA Organic certified, vegan, gluten-free, and made with whole mushroom fruiting bodies rather than mycelium. Cornbread markets this specifically as a daytime-friendly formula — no valerian, no passionflower, nothing designed to make you drowsy.
Pilly Reishi Relax Gummies: what’s on the label
Pilly Labs’ Reishi Relax Gummies use a five-ingredient nighttime blend per the official Pilly Labs Reishi Relax Gummies page:
- Reishi Mushroom Extract — 200 mg
- L-Theanine — 25 mg
- Lemon Balm Extract (Melissa officinalis) — 25 mg
- Passionflower Extract (Passiflora incarnata) — 25 mg
- Valerian Root Extract (Valeriana officinalis) — 25 mg
Pilly Labs lists a single gummy as one serving, with 30 servings per bottle, priced at $47.99 regular, or $40.79 per bottle on subscription. The brand’s own directions say adults should take 2 gummies daily, which means the practical daily intake is double the single-serving numbers above — 400 mg reishi, 50 mg L-theanine, and 50 mg each of lemon balm, passionflower, and valerian root, if you follow that guidance rather than the 1-gummy serving size printed on the panel. The label explicitly flags that passionflower and valerian may cause drowsiness and warns against driving or operating machinery after use, which puts this squarely in nighttime-formula territory rather than an all-day option.
How the reishi dose actually compares
Reishi is the one ingredient both products share, so it’s worth isolating. At the labeled 2-gummy serving, Cornbread delivers 500 mg of reishi extract. At Pilly’s own 2-gummy daily direction, the reishi total comes to 400 mg. Cornbread’s reishi is somewhat higher on a pure milligram basis at that serving size. Neither number is close to the doses used in the clinical research behind reishi — published trials on reishi extract for fatigue and immune markers have generally used 1,500–5,400 mg per day, according to Pilly Labs’ own published dosing-transparency notes for this product. That gap between label dose and study dose is common across the mushroom-gummy category, and it’s exactly the kind of math worth checking on any brand’s blend before assuming a gummy will replicate results from a clinical trial. Our dose-math guide walks through how to do that comparison for any product.
Formula philosophy: single-purpose calm vs. layered sleep support
Cornbread’s approach is minimal by design: reishi for adaptogenic support, ashwagandha (KSM-66, a specific standardized extract with its own research base) for stress response, and L-theanine for a non-sedating calming effect. It’s positioned as something you could take mid-morning before a stressful meeting without feeling foggy afterward.
Pilly Labs’ formula stacks more ingredients aimed specifically at the transition into sleep — lemon balm and L-theanine for the calming layer, then valerian root and passionflower added on top, both of which the label itself flags as sedating. That’s a formula built for evening use, not daytime stress management, and the brand’s own product copy frames it that way, positioning it as a wind-down ritual roughly 30–60 minutes before bed rather than an anytime-of-day option.
Neither approach is inherently better — they’re solving for different times of day. Someone who wants to stay alert during a stressful afternoon and someone who wants help easing into sleep at 9 p.m. are shopping for different jobs, even though both labels say “relax.”
What research suggests about the shared and standalone ingredients
Reishi (Ganoderma lucidum) has traditional use as an adaptogen and has been studied for fatigue, immune markers, and antioxidant activity in several human trials, though results and dosing vary widely across studies. L-theanine, an amino acid found naturally in tea, has research support for reducing stress-related symptoms without sedation, though most trials use doses well above the 25–50 mg found in a gummy serving. Ashwagandha, specifically the KSM-66 extract, has its own body of research on cortisol and stress response at doses generally in the 300–600 mg range. Valerian root and passionflower both have research suggesting they may support sleep and reduce anxiety-like symptoms, but study quality is mixed and doses used in trials are typically several times higher than what’s in either of these gummies. None of this research was conducted on the finished Cornbread or Pilly Labs products — it applies to the individual ingredients studied on their own, and individual results from any gummy may vary.
Price and cost per day
On the numbers as published: Cornbread’s jar runs $34.99 for 50 gummies (25 two-gummy servings), or about $1.40 per daily serving at full price, dropping to roughly $0.91 per day on subscription. Pilly Labs’ bottle runs $47.99 for 30 gummies; following the brand’s 2-gummy daily direction, that’s 15 days of supply per bottle, working out to roughly $3.20 per day at full price and about $2.72 per day on subscription.
Who each formula may fit — and who should be cautious
Cornbread’s daytime formula may be worth considering for someone who wants a calming supplement they can take without drowsiness during work hours. Pilly Labs’ nighttime formula may fit someone specifically looking for a wind-down ritual before bed. Either way, anyone who is pregnant or nursing, taking sedative or anti-anxiety medications, managing a diagnosed medical condition, or under 18 should talk to a healthcare provider before starting either product — both labels say as much directly. Because Pilly Labs’ formula contains valerian root and passionflower, it also carries a specific warning against driving or operating machinery after use, which isn’t present on Cornbread’s daytime formula.
What the label proves, what it suggests, and what’s still unknown
What the label proves: exact ingredient names and per-serving milligram amounts, for both products, with no hidden proprietary blends. What research suggests: individually studied ingredients like reishi, L-theanine, ashwagandha, valerian, and passionflower may support relaxation, stress response, or sleep quality in some study populations. What remains unknown: whether either finished gummy, at its specific combination and dose, produces the same effect for a given person as the standalone research on its individual ingredients. Our guide to reading a mushroom supplement label covers how to spot the difference between a research-backed ingredient and a research-backed product claim. For a closer look at the Pilly Labs formula specifically, see our full Reishi Relax Gummies review.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which product has more reishi per day?
At their respective label-recommended daily servings, Cornbread’s 2-gummy serving provides 500 mg of reishi extract, while Pilly Labs’ 2-gummy daily direction provides 400 mg. Both are below the doses used in most reishi clinical research.
Is either of these gummies a sleep aid or a treatment for anxiety?
No. Neither product is marketed, labeled, or intended as a treatment, cure, or prevention for any medical condition, including insomnia or anxiety disorders. They are dietary supplements, and research suggests some ingredients may support relaxation or wind-down routines.
Can I take the Pilly Labs gummies during the day like the Cornbread formula?
Pilly Labs’ label specifically warns that its valerian root and passionflower content may cause drowsiness and advises against driving or operating machinery after use, which points toward evening rather than daytime use. Cornbread’s formula is marketed as non-drowsy and daytime-friendly.
Do either of these products contain THC or CBD?
Cornbread’s Mushroom Relax Gummies are hemp-free and contain no CBD or THC, per the brand’s product FAQ. Pilly Labs’ formula also does not list hemp-derived cannabinoids among its ingredients.
Which is cheaper per day?
Based on published list pricing and each brand’s own recommended daily serving, Cornbread works out to a lower cost per day than Pilly Labs at full price. Actual pricing can change, so confirm current numbers at checkout before comparing.
These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. This content is for educational purposes only and is not medical advice. Ask a qualified healthcare professional about supplements, medications, pregnancy, or health conditions.
Leave a Reply